Makeup Dilemma

I'm hoping someone will have an answer to an annoying problem I have: eyeliner that leaves me looking like a raccoon. I use primer on my face and eyelids every day, but tonight is not the first time I've come home looking like a navy raccoon. I use a cream eyeliner pencil I really like and hasn't given me problems until recently and I've tried Urban Decay and Bare Minerals eyeshadow primer along with Bare Minerals and Laura Mercier foundation primer.

I don't think I rub my eyes during the day, but I'm starting to wonder if it's become an unconscious habit since I've had so much eye strain lately. The bottom corner of my right eye has started twitching as the day goes on, so I know my eyes are tired. Maybe I am an eye-rubber?

Any tips for better eyeliners or primers would be great-especially if you don't want to be seen with someone who looks like they've been on the wrong side of a heavyweight wrestler!!